07-26-11
WCSO Corruption?
Whatcom County
,...Uncovered has learned of a rather interesting series of circumstances within the Whatcom County Sheriff's Office that has many people puzzled as to why this hasn't heretofore been reported by any "mainstream" local media sources and why it happened in the first place. It has left a number of federal, state, county and municipal law enforcers scratching their heads trying to explain what appears to be the inexplicable.
WC,...U has learned from confidential sources that a former WCSO Sgt., now a Chief Inspector of the WCSO Internal Investigations Unit, was involved with a young girl, who was at the time an explorer cadet with the sheriff's explorer program in the 2005 to 2006 time-frame.
Sources indicate that the girl was allegedly involved with the man that Sheriff Elfo later promoted to the position of Patrol Lieutenant, immediately following an internal investigation that found he did have a relationship with the girl. Elfo then promoted the man again a short time later, to Chief Inspector. WC,...U additionally found that the man had in fact been romantically involved with the girl, a minor at the time of these incidents, and had served her alcohol on at least two occasions.
A number of documents have surfaced, purported to be the original and legitimate internal documents that were leaked from within the WCSO, as well as from the girl herself, and the father of a childhood friend of the girl, a sort-of father figure to the girl, which detail the relationship that existed between herself and the man who is now charged with investigating the alleged misdeeds of other WCSO staff.
In addition to these allegations, it was further learned the the man that reported the misdeeds to Sheriff Elfo, the father of the girl's childhood friend, who she had called for support and guidance, then became the target of a series of questionable internal investigations himself in what appears to have been retaliatory and maliciously motivated, all because the man had reported the incidents to Sheriff Elfo in the first place.
WC,...U found that the girl allegedly had been taken out for a birthday celebration, by the then married WCSO Sgt., where she was served alcohol the first time. Then, after being taken to his home later in the evening, the WCSO Sgt. served the girl alcohol a second time and she subsequently lost consciousness for a period of time and has no recollection of what occurred after that.
The girl reported waking up sometime later and felt very uncomfortable about what had occurred and decided to walk herself home alone, despite the vocal opposition of the man that brought her to his flat. A conflict of some sort occurred between the girl and the WCSO Sgt., which resulted in her being followed by the man to her Lynden, WA home in a manner that can only be described as stalking behavior.
WC,...U found these allegations very hard to believe, but after exhaustive research on the topic and interviews with a number of the persons involved, has found that the allegations are supported by facts, the WCSO's own documents and a formal discipline that Sheriff Elfo meted out to the man after findings concluded that minimally, the man did serve alcohol to a minor, in violation of law and a number of the WCSO's own policies.
Sheriff Elfo didn't fire this man and even promoted him? Yes.
Wait, it gets worse yet. Not only did Sheriff Elfo apparently promote the perpetrator of these acts, but it was found that the man had written letters to the newly enlisted girl's US Air Force commanding general in what appears to have been an attempt to scare her into silence about what occurred and as a "reminder", as in a veiled threat, that her grandmother, the girl's only real family, was still within the jurisdiction where he lived at the time, Lynden, WA.
WC,...U has been told that the Undersheriff at that time, Undersheriff James, had wanted to fire the man for his unbelievable and unconscionable actions, essentially making himself unfit for any law enforcement post, based on what he had allegedly committed, but was prevented from doing so by Sheriff Elfo.
We're not done yet.
WC,...U has also learned that case appears to tie in with the unusual termination of the former head of the Whatcom County Department of Emergency Management (DEM). As odd as it sounds, the man that was allegedly responsible for the WCSO Sgt. not being charged criminally for serving alcohol to a minor, a Lynden PD detective, was also the same man that brought criminal charges against the former head of DEM, resulting in his arrest and subsequent conviction for an unusual misdemeanor crime, under unusual and specious circumstances.
The man that was responsible for the WCSO's part of the DEM internal investigation, resulting in the former DEM head's termination? You may have already guessed it, but it was allegedly the former WCSO Sgt., the same man that had earlier not been charged criminally by Lynden PD, or fired by the WCSO, the same man that had since been promoted twice by Sheriff Elfo to the head of Elfo's Internal Investigations Unit. It has been alleged that this was an apparent quid pro quo between the two men, for their own personal reasons.
WC,...U has also learned that there is a current civil lawsuit that has been brought by the former DEM head, against the City of Lynden and the Lynden PD detective involved with this case.
WC,...U will continue to investigate and follow developments in this series of allegations and will report the updates as more information becomes available.
~
Editor
The above referenced documents can be found on the Scribd document hosting service:
Whatcom County Sheriff's Office Corruption
07-24-11
Letter to the Editor: Whatcom County,...
Uncovered

Re: Whatcom County Sheriff's Election
I had thought about writing a letter to the Editor of the Bellingham Herald, but then I figured “What’s the point?”, they’ll just edit my words and probably delete the key parts, as they have in the past, and my alleged “opinion” would no longer be mine.
Then I see this morning that my wife’s letter opposing Bill Elfo for sheriff of Whatcom County was actually printed, albeit with minor alterations, and I decided what the heck, I have someone that could put my letter, UNALTERED, onto their webpage. It may not get the same level of readership, but at least I know my words will be MY words.
As far as Sheriff Elfo goes, I do not support him. The reasons are varied and the “backstory” is complex. Some of the reasons are unbelievable and if I told you all the gory details, I’d be fired for some trumped-up alleged violation of one thing or another, as has already been attempted internally several times now. Trust me when I tell you this, you would just not believe the staggering incompetence and unethical actions that have taken place recently inside the WCSO, under Elfo’s direction.
I know the details. I can name names, but I also have 10 years invested in that office, several of which are B.E. (before Elfo), and this line of work, and the thought of throwing it all away is not very appealing. The “conduct unbecoming an officer” and “insubordination” discipline games that are routinely played internally make it tough to even have an opinion, first of all, but much tougher to openly express it. The younger folks just won’t. I’m one of few that refuse to cow to Elfo’s tyrannical intimidation games, or “drink the kool-aid” as we like to call it amongst ourselves.
So, here’s my story of Bill Elfo, if you will indulge me a bit of your time.
I was once a supporter of Sheriff Elfo and I once had respect for the man that was appointed to fill the position vacated by Dale Brandland many years ago. It wasn’t that I didn’t like Dale Brandland, because I did and still do like Dale Brandland as a person, but one could see that his heart just wasn’t in law enforcement anymore. One could see it was time and that he saw greener pastures elsewhere.
Dale is a decent and honest family man that could be counted to “do the right thing” and that’s more than I can say for Bill Elfo now. It was more, it seemed, that Dale was interested in higher aspirations that took his time away from the office and we had serious concerns about internal issues that were not being addressed, or addressed entirely improperly by unsupervised minions, so it seemed that change was in order and that change came when Dale stepped out and Bill Elfo stepped in.
At first, it was the classic honeymoon period and everyone was smiles and backslapping. People got along and we felt like we had a team again, perhaps even a family. The Whatcom County Deputy Sheriff’s Guild (WCDSG) and the Whatcom County Sheriff’s Office (WCSO) administration were once again partners, it seemed, in a common goal for the common good. Respect was a two way street and it was practiced by all.
WCDSG was granted proposals we had been requesting for some time, things the Brandland team never seemed to have time to address or even listen to in many instances. Things to improve our own efficiencies and to better serve the public began to happen and we were happy.
We put forth various “win-win” proposals, which were accepted and approved by Elfo. We were all riding tall in the saddle because a “cop’s cop” was in the big office at the end of the long hallway now and we all felt like our opinions mattered again. We all felt like the little empires that had been built internally, and the unethical, would now be reined in or removed. We all felt like it was going to be a level playing field for all.
As time progressed, however, the shine began to fade and the smiles started turning to frowns and stern looks when little cliques of insider’s began to form, again, and favorites began to emerge, again, as preferential treatment became obvious and the reasons for it equally as obvious. It started to become dysfunctional and toxic. The trust we once shared was slipping away rapidly and no one seemed to care, not even Elfo.
We also began to see some truly perplexing decisions that were being made by Elfo, some of which to this day are not explained, that defy common sense and logic. We thought amongst ourselves “Well, the honeymoon is over”, accepting that even Elfo, the “cop’s cop”, was just a man, that no one is perfect and it was great while it lasted. At least we could still count on what matters most, like trust, ethics and honesty, right?
Enter the phase we’re in now. Being a friend of Bill became the fast lane. Drink the kool-aid, do as you’re told, as in “follow orders”, and your days will be bright and full of plenty, usually in the form of some specialty assignment, some specialized piece of equipment or some special training. Cross Elfo, in any way, rightful or not, ethical or not, truthful or not, and you’re done, as in finis’, as many have now found for themselves and what I might also ultimately find before this reign of Elfo is over.
In this current environment, this trained, experienced and decorated military man of means and skill, who has accomplished things in this world, who had a life full of experience before entering law enforcement, who knows a flim-flam or double-talk when he sees it, became an anathema to Elfo. As others have as well. I, like others, can tolerate a lot of things, but I’ll not be lied to, and I’ll not be mistreated by anyone, and that includes Bill Elfo, et al.
Believe me, I’d love to, but I just cannot go into all the sordid details of internal matters publicly without laying my neck squarely on the chopping block and giving Elfo what he and his minions need to terminate my employment. That’s right, I can’t even be truthful in public, about matters of public concern, about matters concerning employees of the public, paid by tax dollars from the public, without the risk of termination. Why? You want to know what Elfo et al fear most? Public scrutiny. What are the Bellingham Herald, Lynden Tribune, KGMI et al delivering? Cheerleading for Elfo. Do the math….
In reality, Elfo hasn’t really done much personally to advance our goals and make Whatcom County a better place to live and work. Oh he'll take credit for it all, but the credit for the achievements of the WCSO goes almost entirely to the superb, dedicated and motivated men and women of the WCSO that make it what it is, not Elfo. How many patrol shifts has Elfo pulled? Zero. How many arrests has Elfo made? Zero. How many crime rings has Elfo busted up? Zero. How much crime intelligence has Elfo gathered? Zero. How many cases has Elfo solved? Again, zero.
Elfo does deserve credit for one small thing: For getting out of the way of deputies and letting them do their jobs. (That seemingly small task was quite a challenge for the previous administration.) There are many, but I’ll pick one example of something that Elfo likes to take personal credit for: “meth labs”. They do still exist here, but the reality is that we had very little to do with shutting most of them down.
It was like a giant whack-a-mole game with meth labs, until the pseudo-ephedrine (cold medicine) control laws came into play. The problem literally took care of itself after that. More than that, it was mostly a problem of Mexican “super labs”, that we here had nothing at all to do with interdicting. That credit goes entirely to the feds, but it does make for a grandiose claim for Elfo, no?
Now let’s talk about what Elfo has not solved in 8 years in his seat. Elfo was a big cheerleader for a new jail,… 8 years ago. In fact, he was very vocal about getting a voter approved initiative for a new .1% tax, earmarked specifically for that new jail. 8 years later, no jail and no plan for a jail. I bet we'll line some more pockets with tax dollars with another new focus group or a new commission though.
8 years of taxes later and nobody has any idea where the tax money is and how much is there. If you ask, you’ll get the generic “general fund” answer. Ahh, but we’re great about running up the “talk about a new jail” gin now that it’s election time again. Never underestimate the power of an election to make people play nice and dust off old unsolved issues of the past.
Where is the new records management system (RMS) to streamline our efforts, bring us into the 21st century of law enforcement and to stop wasting so much time, effort, energy and paper writing reports like we did in the 50’s?
Why doesn’t Whatcom County, still, to this day, not share records data with the rest of Washington State law enforcement agencies on a free data sharing system called LinX? We’re about the last that hasn’t and it has not gone unnoticed by the rest of the state.
Let’s talk about the minimum staffing levels for patrol that have not changed in anyone’s recent memory. In fact, we can account as far as 20 years back and we don’t know exactly when they were last increased. 3 deputies for day-shift, 4 for swing-shift and 3 for graveyard shift and the county has grown significantly in that time.
Granted, shift overlaps and 10 hour shifts have helped, but the fact remains that a key facet of county law enforcement coverage, for nearly 2200 square miles of border county territory, has still not been addressed in 8 years. Elfo’s answer: Online internet reporting. Keep that in mind the next time you’re waiting a long time to hear back on a 911 call.
Let’s talk about the countless thousands of staff level administrator hours wasted conducting politically motivated Pavlovian “internal investigations” for those that dare to speak up or cross Elfo. Oh, the stories that could be told.
Let’s talk about the chief henchman, who Elfo personally appointed to head that post he created, who owes Elfo so much, deeply and personally. Let’s talk about the young girl who still struggles with the fallout and the fears of that abuse to this day. It will be said that he doesn’t have a choice and that “the union” forced his hand. That’s a lie. There is no “union” representation above the Sergeant level. That man occupies the seat Elfo created for him, because that’s what Elfo wants. That’s simply a fact.
What about the absolutely horrendous 911 communications and police radio problems that are still a problem and have even gotten worse in the 8 years since Elfo took the helm. What he inherited is not his fault and I’m not saying it is, but it's 2011 and we still can't figure out how to make a phone line work? Really? Will a citizen of Whatcom County, officer, deputy or trooper need to die from a radio problem before it's taken seriously and solved? 8 YEARS wasn't enough? Really?
I could go on, but you get the point. Hopefully.
An additional point is that there are two deputies running against Elfo. Steve Harris and Bob Taylor. Give that some thought. This isn’t just an open expression of disagreement or disapproval. Those two men are literally putting their law enforcement futures on the line, as am I, to correct the problems we now have. That takes real guts and real dedication in this environment. Would you do the same? Either man would be a better choice than Elfo.
So, in closing, Elfo is the last person I’d support for sheriff. As a matter of fact, I’d vote for an old soup can before I’d vote for Elfo. An empty front office would be better than what we have now.
As an aside, you should ask Elfo about his alligator jar in his office sometime. My business card may well be added to that jar before this is over.
I think it's time to add Elfo's card to it.
Paul Murphy; father, husband, friend, veteran, tax payer, voter, citizen, businessman, farmer,
mechanic and peace officer.
P.S: I see that Marvin Wolff also wrote a glowing letter of praise to the Herald about Elfo. It’s like the straw man phone calls he’s made to KGMI when Elfo was being interviewed, pretending to be an “anonymous” caller. (Yes, Marvin, we know it was you.) I’d imagine Marvin would surely want to see Elfo stay. No one knows exactly what Marvin does in that office, who he answers to, or what function he serves (we’ve been told many things over the years), but he’s got his own office in the WCSO and more importantly, he has Elfo’s ear…
07-11-11
Long Overdue
It's been quite a long time since the last update. Over two years by the date on the last post. Many things have happened in the time since and there has been much water under the bridge.
Whatcom County,...Uncovered elected to take a break from the local for awhile to focus on other larger national issues, but now it's time to again begin turning the spotlight on local matters. So, for many reasons, we're choosing to start up again.
The local media has proven that they are not willing to be anything but cheerleaders for certain causes and certain issues, and censors of others. Reporting the good is preferable, and as important, but so is reporting the not so good. Reporting one, but not the other, can only be called cheer-leading. It's certainly not journalism and is often a reflection of the corruption that reigns in Whatcom County.
So reacquire and retune. We hope to change that balance of power.
Watch for coming updates. You can also find us on facebook now too.
~ Editor